Today, PinkNews wrote up a study claiming that āTrans athletes could actually be physically disadvantaged in some areasā.
Funded by the International Olympic Committee (IOC) and published in the British Journal of Sports Medicine, the study looked at ā75 transgender and cisgender athletes, comparing the strength, power and aerobic capacity of the two groups.ā
According to the article: āTrans women were seen to perform worse than their cis peers in certain cardiovascular tests, and to have less lower-body strength. The bone density of transgender women was also found to be similar to that of cis female athletes.ā
Looks like we were wrong all along! Trans women can be just as bad at sports as biological women; worse even! Good news, guys: this proves we are exactly the same⦠(I think the conclusion weāre meant to come to.)
Anyway, I thought Iād look into this study, and I have some of my own findings to shareā¦
Perhaps the strangest thing is that it inadvertently sides with gender critical feminists, in its assertion that trans/non-trans cohorts are biologically different; itās just that the study tries to claim a disadvantage in the opposite direction.
It immediately takes off in an ideological direction, the abstract using the word ācisgenderā - a very scientific term that everyone clearly agrees on. You can really sense youāre in the midst of serious academia here:
āMarginalisedā researchers
Moreover, we are told that two authors of the study are āmembers of a marginalised communityā, one a ātransgender womanā and another a ājunior (to make her sound extra-marginalised)⦠woman from the global south.ā Not sure what this is meant to mean in the context of a paper sponsored by an international committee (the IOC).
There are two methodological flaws I spotted within about five minutes of reading the report:
Where are the athletes?
Although the title is Strength, power and aerobic capacity of transgender athletes: a cross-sectional study, the participants donāt actually seem to be athletes. In fact, they are people who āwere recruited through social media advertising on Meta Platforms⦠and Xā.
Later on researchers even concede that the āfindings may not be generalisable to global athlete populationsā and āNo cisgender or transgender athletes [study participants] were competing at the national or international level.ā So yeah, not actual athletes.
Self-reporting measures
The next issue is that one of the key bits of data used was self-ratings (a subjective measure). Participants were ārequired to participate in competitive sports or undergo physical training at least three times per weekā (practically the same thing as being an athlete) and then had to āself-rate their training intensity for each session on a scale of 1-10 (10=maximum intensity)'.ā Non-athletesā impressions of their workout difficult is not exactly Einstein levels of scienceā¦
Next up, letās take a look at some of the people involved in the study.
I was interested to see that one of the researchers, Professor Yannis Pitsiladis, is on the Medical and Scientific Commission of the IOC (which funded the study). I mean, Iām no academic expert, but it all sounds a little bit āfriendlyā between researcher and commissioner.
Pitsiladis has worked on related research with some of those involved in this project, such as Blair Hamilton. Both are authors of Integrating transwomen athletes into elite competition: The case of elite archery, a 2021 project.
Hamilton is from the School of Sport and Health Sciences at the University of Brighton, and described as āa trailblazer in the world of sports researchā.
Some may recognise Hamilton from this heartwarming BBC article in 2019 about āherā playing for Stonehaven Ladies FC in Scotland.
"There is absolutely no advantage on the pitchā, Hamilton explained at the time.
Although a āsheā in the piece, the University of Brighton research portal uses the pronoun ātheyā to describe Hamilton.
It reads: āwhether they're peeling back the layers of gender inclusivity in sports or uncovering the hidden secrets of our bones, Blair Hamilton is a force to be reckoned with, leading the charge towards a brighter, more informed future for athletes of all backgrounds.ā
Sounds very scientific, doesnāt itā¦
Hereās another piece on āherā from 2020:
Hamilton is in a better place than most to comment on trans inclusion in sport having taken part in menās sport and womenās sport as a trans woman, but also through her work ā she is now doing a PHD at the University of Brighton researching the very topic.Ā
Because being personally involved in an issue definitely makes you the right person to study itā¦
Furthermore it reads:
āBeing male-born, the general argument which Iām trying to disprove in my research is that trans women have an advantage and that youāre taking a place away from a girlā.
So hereās Hamilton actually saying they/ she is ātrying to disprove⦠that trans women have an advantage and that youāre taking a place away from a girlā. Working backwards is hardly the scientific method.
Reading between the lines, I canāt help wonder if Hamilton is just not very good at sportsā¦
Money, money, money
Of course, after all this nonsense I was keen to find out how much the IOC is spending on these studies. Sadly the figures are buried deep (if anyone has any ideas, Iām all ears; I am not Erin Brockovich yet).
However, I did find some of the other research the IOC funded in an inventory last updated this month:
It Takes a Village: An Inventory and Analysis of Athletes' Villages in the United Kingdom - Robert Sroka, Northumbria University, United Kingdom
Challenging the gender dichotomy?: Examining Olympic Channel content, production, and audiences through a gendered lens - Qingru Xu, The University of Alabama, USA.
Cutting-edge stuff!









